Home > Vintages and Regions > Bordeaux > Bordeaux 1989 > Tasting, May 2000
Bordeaux 1989: Tasting, May 2000
As I have written in my vintage review, 1989 was as close to the perfect growing season as you could perhaps hope for. Persistently warm and sunny weather, punctuated with occasional showers sufficient prophylaxis against the hydric stresses that would otherwise come with drought. Having given a nod to the left bank communes in that introduction, and specifically commented on lesser achievements in Margaux, it was instructive in this tasting to take a look at that commune in particular, sampling half a dozen wines of the appellation, together with two near neighbours that qualify as Haut-Médoc.
On the night Palmer was streets ahead, although there was also a very good showing fro Brane-Cantenac, one of the usual suspects in the litany of under-performing Margaux chateaux. Not so here, any prejudices having been accounted for by our usual blind-tasting rigmarole. In fact, across the tasting, all the wines performed very well indeed. I can not of course extrapolate such a focused assessment to comment on the vintage as a whole, nevertheless I feel that these wines certainly give an indication of the quality that this vintage has always had to offer. (21/5/00)
Bordeaux 1989 - Tasting Notes
Tasted in May 2000. Click
to locate stockists.
Chateau d'Angludet (Margaux) 1989:
A good colour. The nose has an elegant bouquet, although
there is also a sooty note suggestive of tannins. With
time the nose opens out, to develop considerable
fragrance. This is a big and aggressive wine when it
comes to the palate. Lots of tannin, supporting some
rich, blackcurrant fruit. Low acidity. Finishes with a
coating of tannin. Needs another three to five years at
least. 17+/20
![]()
Chateau Lascombes (Margaux) 1989: This
wine has a slightly paler colour, but it still has an
attractive appearance. Quite a bit of funk on the nose,
although this seems to blow off with aeration. More sooty
notes here as well, and I wonder if this is going to be a
very tannic evening. There is more development with this
wine, however, as fragrant aromas and notes of cigar box
show themselves. On the palate, elegant and fragrant
blackcurrant fruit. A full and richly flavoured
midpalate, again fairly tannic but less so than the
previous wine. A full bodied and smoothly textured
mouthful, leading to more cigar box on the finish. Drinking very well now
if decanted. 17/20
![]()
Chateau
Labégorce-Zédé (Margaux) 1989: Lovely colour. A rose-petal and
tobacco leaf nose. This wine also has good balance,
although there are more prominent tannins. Well-built,
fruit laden palate. Low acidity. Finishes well, but
short. Great for drinking now, but doesn't have the
substance of the other wines. 17/20
![]()
Chateau Palmer (Margaux) 1989: We
have clearly taken a step up in quality here. A lovely
colour. A wonderful, complex and fragrant nose, with
hints of fresh coffee grounds. The forepalate is rich,
round and full, and although this sensation persists the
midpalate is dominated by the tannins which give this wine such
structure. Lots of fat, ripe fruit, yet quite elegant and perfumed with
it. The tannins persist after the finish. A great wine. Needs five years
at least. 18.5+/20
![]()
Chateau Brane-Cantenac (Margaux) 1989:
This wine has the deepest colour by far. The nose seems rich, austere and
complex. This is a big and rich wine. A fruit-packed palate, with a massive
structure. There are tannins everywhere, matched by good acidity. This is a wine
built for the long haul, and still very much on the way up. This needs five to
ten years at least. 17.5+/20
![]()
Pavillon Rouge du Chateau Margaux (Margaux) 1989: The second wine of
Margaux. A good colour here. Another fruit
laden wine, much more evident on the nose here. A touch
of caramel oak (just a touch), some good ground coffee
notes and a hint of sooty tannins. Another big wine on
the palate. Very tannic, rich, with loads of fruit. More
fresh coffee, some fragrance developing, leading into a
big, tannic finish. A good length. Overall a serious
wine. Needs another
five years. 17.5+/20
![]()
Chateau Cantemerle
(Haut-Médoc) 1989:
This wine and the next vie for position of most richly
coloured wine of the flight. A perfumed nose, with
cigar box and freshly rolled tobacco leaves. Another elegant palate, with
a good balance, although with plentiful summer berry fruits. Full
bodied, maintaining a smooth, rounded texture through the palate.
Finishes well, and has good length. Tannins much more integrated than
the previous wines. Ready for drinking now. 17/20
![]()
Chateau La Lagune
(Haut-Médoc) 1989: Another well coloured wine. On the nose, big creamy
toffee and vanilla aromas give the identity away. More big tannins on the
forepalate with this wine, with ripe fruits and creamy vanilla. A fragrant edge.
Tannic. Good fruit through the midpalate, persisting on the finish. Probably
ready now with decanting. The presence of still perceptible oak is typical of La
Lagune. 17/20
![]()
