Home > Vintages and Regions > Loire > Loire Extravaganza 2005
Loire Extravaganza 2005
My
recent sojourns in the Loire were becoming a part of my annual routine, so
much so that I really missed the place this year when, for various reasons -
including a new job and a consequent relocation of my family in a new house in a
new city - I couldn't visit. There have been compensations, such as trips to
Bandol and Chianti instead, but there seemed a more obvious way to get my Loire
fix.....
During the Summer (and it has been a very good Summer up here on the East coast of Scotland) I pulled a selection of young wines from my cellar for tasting. As these wines were mostly purchased at the domaine, in six-packs or cases, it's quite acceptable to open and drink, even in such obvious youth, in order to assess how the wines are faring in bottle.
To create a little ambience, I've included a few images of my favourite Loire chateaux (hold your mouse over each to see the name). If you like, squint at a picture of your choosing and pretend you're really there, preferably with a decent glass of Vouvray to hand. (18/10/05)
Loire Extravaganza 2005 - Tasting Notes
Tasted during Summer 2005. Click
to locate stockists.
Anjou is often ignored as a source of good and interesting wine, but as I have learnt this attitude is a mistake. As always, conscientious producers turn out good examples. Nevertheless, many would regard Savennières as a step up in quality. This little-known appellation spawns some classic, structured, surprisingly ageworthy wines. Traditionally the style is said to be off-dry, but many are now turning out super dry wines. As for Sancerre, as a student I must confess this wine was a significant feature in my cellar (and those were the days when I had a proper cellar, a dank underground space beneath our late Victorian terraced house). I seem to have drifted away from the appellation over the years, preferring the delights of Chenin to Sauvignon, but was glad to taste even the most basic cuvées of Alphonse Mellot here; clearly a great talent.
VGL Anjou Les Roches 2003: Barrel fermented, with eleven months in oak thereafter. Fairly rich,
golden hue. Honey and straw, a suggestion of minerality. Good palate. Very dry,
but with a firm weight and some good grip. Good flavour, woolly, honey-edged
green fruit. A peppery character throughout. Rather a harsh bitterness, probably
oak derived, present towards the finish which is the main detractor.
Nevertheless enjoyable, in a very rustic way. 15/20
![]()
Domaine des
Baumard Savennières Trie de Speciale 2000: An appealing golden colour with
more than a little depth. Very mineral in character, smoky stone fruit, with
nuances of orange and thyme. Rich palate, with the suggestion of
botrytis-derived flavours, but bone dry, with plentiful and firm alcohol, and
grippy structure, providing for a rather foursquare, masculine mouthfeel and
presence. This is clearly in need of bottle age in order to soften and develop,
and is bristling with potential. Very good. 17+/20
![]()
Domaine des
Baumard Savennières Clos du Papillon 1999: Good, shimmering pale lemon hue.
The nose is delightful, proffering great minerality, with notes of melon,
pineapple, crystalline tropical fruits. Fresh, firm, minerally palate. The
midpalate is packed with grip. Real tangible extract, lemony acidity, joyous
presence on the palate, and a liquorice twist on the finish. Showing much more
flavour, grippy structure and potential than when tasted at the domaine. This
wine will do
well in the cellar, for five years at least. Very good indeed, could be
excellent. 17.5+/20
![]()
Domaine des
Baumard Savennières Clos du Papillon 1994: Rich, deep, golden colour. An
amazingly expressive nose, with minerals and chalk, honey botrytis, lemon and
orange, and powdered rocks. Great richness is the impression, borne out on the
palate, but with an almost paradoxical bone dry structure. Pervasive,
flamboyant, fresh, with a fine, honeyed texture backed up by rocky minerality
and great acidity, this is superb. Showing much better than my last tasting, and
my estimated drinking window from my last bottle may be a little conservative -
this could go one for years and years. Excellent. 18+/20
![]()
Alphonse Mellot Sancerre La Moussière 2003: Pale hue. Lovely nose, showing lots of
minerality, chalky and gunpowdery, flinty even, but with a little ripe melon
fruit to give some roundness to the aromas. Deliciously fresh and yet ripe,
flavoursome palate. The chalky, stony character comes through, with some nice
grip and plenty of firm, stony presence. Although this is balanced out by notes
of pear, and fleshy white stone fruit. This is lovely stuff, and shows what
Sauvignon is capable of given the right environment, and the right hands. 17/20
![]()
Alphonse Mellot
Sancerre Rosé La Moussière 2004: A very pale pink. Aromatic, leafy red fruit
nose. Some vanilla cream, and notes of thyme too. Full, flavoursome palate.
It has clean acidity, and quite a grippy finish. This is accompanied by a
pleasing, leafy, raspberry and strawberry character. Good. 15/20
![]()
Certainly a contender for the
region's greatest appellation, Vouvray still exists today thanks mainly to the
late Gaston Huet, onetime vigneron, mayor of
Vouvray and an instrumental
figure in preventing the vineyards being replaced by a TGV express line.
Although my cellar includes a number of Huet Vouvrays, young and maturing, I
decided not to pull any of these. I stuck with the young, recently purchased
wines from two other favourite domaines. These represent two ends of the style
spectrum available here; wonderfully mineral, fresh, dry Chenin in one hand, and
in the other (this is beginning to sound like a good tasting!) the rich, sweet
style, often helped along by botrytis.
Champalou Vouvray Clos du Portail 2002:
Wonderful, aromatic, mineral, plump pineapple and dried fruit nose. Classic
Chenin with a stony edge, and suggesting a little more richness on the nose than
previously. Beautiful palate, with fresh yet weighty mineral fruit. This has
real grip and verve, and displays superb balance that causes the wine to simply
glide across the palate. Continues to open out, building weight and flavour,
before a pepper-laden finish. Quite some length too. Fantastic wine, which may
yet develop further. 17+/20
![]()
Champalou Vouvray Cuvée Mouelleuse 2002:
Pale hue. Water-light nose, floral and suggestive of delicate sweetness. Sweet,
weighty, balanced palate, showing fresh, floral, slightly minty white fruit.
Full structure, with fine acidity and a little grip. This is pleasant now, but
brimming with potential for the future. My score reflects hope of development
rather than current pleasure - this needs ten years minimum. 18+/20
![]()
Domaine des Aubuisières Vouvray Cuvée
de Silex
2003: A very pale, limpid hue. Delightful nose that carries me straight back
to my tasting in Bernard Fouquet's cave; ripe pears, and also freshly
picked mint. Lovely presence on the palate, showing a little fatness in keeping
with the ripe vintage. Good mineral character, a little white pepper on a
slightly drier finish. Simply lovely style. Drink now or over the next five years. 16.5+/20
![]()
Domaine des Aubuisières Vouvray Cuvée Alexandre Moelleux 2003: Just a little
deeper than the Cuvée Silex, but not much. A pleasing, mineral-laden nose,
showing some herb-tinged tangerine skin, melon and pear. And what a palate; creamy yet balanced
on entry, showing great concentration and also moderate weight, building through
the midpalate. And then an expanse of flavour, touched with joyful nuances of
caramel (reminiscent of Baumard's 2001 Quarts de Chaume) and ripe melon fruit,
which slowly fades along an elegant finish. Super length. This is stunning. Will
go for years, maybe decades. An elevated score. 19+/20
![]()
I tasted just two red wines, to make a cursory nod towards the Loire's major red variety, Cabernet Franc. I was speaking on the subject of Loire Reds only yesterday with Simon Taylor of Stone, Vine & Sun; he told me they will be listing fewer such wines in the future as they just don't sell. What a shame, especially with such good recent vintages, the balanced, elegant 2002 and the rich, ripe 2003. The latter, from my tastings so far, is an outstanding vintage for Chinon and Bourgueil. I've already begun to purchase said wines, such as Couly-Dutheil's Clos de l'Echo and Joguet's top cuvées, but have left these for future tastings.
Domaine des Roches Neuves Saumur-Champigny
'Terres Chaudes' 2003: Deep, intense, impressive, youthful purple.
This youth is also evident on the nose, which shows a wealth of primary black
cherry and damson fruit aromas, with a little twist of tobacco. Warm, ripe,
expansive palate, showing plenty of conserve black fruit, but not huge or jammy.
Decent acidity, although on the low side, together with soft, ripe tannins which
mean this wine should improve over the next 1-2 years, although it's eminently
enjoyable now. A success, in a successful vintage. 16.5+/20
![]()
Couly-Dutheil Chinon 'Les Chateliére' 2003: Still a deep, purple hue.
A buttery nose, with ripe berry and forest fruits, backed up by a smoky edge.
Full palate, packed with flavour, and still showing obvious, awkward youth.
Soft, ripe, supple tannins lend structure but do not distract. Almost chewy,
tarry, tobacco-laden nuance to the finish. My first impressions were, I think,
correct; this cuvée has piles of potential. Today it shows even more texture.
Very good. Leave another 3-4 years at least. 16+/20
![]()
A stunning, underappreciated, undervalued wine
region. Some vignerons seem to get away with charging an arm and a leg for their
Coteaux du Layon, and yet some seem to charge a pittance. In the latter category
there are some stunning producers, including
Claude Papin and
Jo Pithon, for
instance. I tasted a range of Claude's wines here, among others, and finished
off with two youthful wines from Bellerive. As this was predominantly an
assessment of young wines I left my 1988 and 1990 Bellerive, of which there are
cases in my cellar, well alone....even though these two vintages are drinking
beautifully now.
Chateau Pierre Bise Coteaux du Layon Beaulieu L'Anclaie 2001:
Mid-golden hue. Quite classic nose, showing talc and mineral-infused citrus
fruit, coated in honey. This comes through on the palate, which still
demonstrates a very primary, oily, viscous, honeyed fruit palate, with a
minerality like that on the nose, cut through with some fairly firm acidity.
Whilst lovely to drink now, this is destined to be a long-lived cuvée. Will
improve in bottle over the next decade with ease. Great quality here. 18+/20
![]()
Chateau Pierre Bise
Coteaux du Layon Beaulieu Rouannières 2001:
A tinge of golden colour here. Gorgeous nose; smoky, stony, cordite-infused.
Very organic, almost animalistic character. This is showing lovely development.
Big, rich, sweet, luscious palate. Incisive acidity, which becomes apparent on
the endpalate once the seductive texture has played its part. That organic,
minerally character again. Lemons, oranges, botrytis? This is simply superb, and
also shows great development compared to my tasting at the domaine. Great
length. 18+/20
![]()
Chateau Pierre Bise Coteaux du Layon Beaulieu Clos de la Soucherie 2001:
Elegant, fruit dominated nose, a touch ethereal, showing botrytis with a
little exposure to air. Rich, apricot, honey, mineral character on the palate,
matched by sufficient acidity. Mouth-coating, expansive, almost luscious feel.
But has great balance. Shows some grip at the finish. Long, lingering presence.
Delicious, with superb potential; should improve over the next 5-8 years. 18+/20
![]()
Chateau Pierre Bise Quarts des Chaume 2001:
Attractive, light-golden colour. Intense nose; chalky, mineral, botrytis
character, with wild honey, honeysuckle and pepper. Sweet, impressive palate,
with plenty of impact from the moment of entry. Lovely acidity, countering the
rich, oily, viscous style. Minerally, organic, savoury yet seductive. Great
length. Very good indeed, with great potential. 18.5+/20
![]()
Delesvaux Coteaux du Layon St
Aubin Clos du Pavillon 1998: Rich, burnished
orange-gold. Lovely nose, heady and aromatic, with plenty of rich orange and
quince character, with a firm volcanic mineral streak as well. Rich yet
balanced, with an appealingly, slightly bitter structure. Absolutely packed with
mineral influences, smoke and gunpowder. Superb wine for what is essentially a
lesser vintage. Good length. 17.5+/20
![]()
Petit Metris
Coteaux du Layon St Aubin 2002: Lemon gold hue. Interesting nose, with a chalky minerality
alongside notes of grapefruit, blood orange, . Moderate weight, not showing a
huge presence of residual sugar. Nicely balanced though; good, firm acidity
alongside a very firm structure. Very good, zesty, sharp impact on the palate,
with a lemon pith and black pepper character. It has the acidity to go for some time
in the cellar. Should drink well for 10-15 years. 16.5+/20
![]()
Petit Metris Quarts de Chaume
1998: Deep, slightly burnished, golden hue. A very interesting, expressive
nose; quite organic in character. Dried straw predominates, with aromas of wet
wool, and rocky mineral notes alongside. Quite woody too, although this
dissipates. Immediately apparent
on the palate is a sherbetty spritz. Good character as on the
nose, showing classic Chenin flavour with a depth of chalky minerality. Fresh
acidity and lovely weighty texture. Certainly a wine that reflects its origins,
with the advantage of being quite approachable now, although it should drink
well for a decade. Very good indeed. 17.5+/20
![]()
Chateau Bellerive Quarts de Chaume
2002: A very pale, shimmering lemon-gold hue compared to the two slightly older
cuvées, Very simple on the nose, just a little floral element. On the palate it
has exquisite balance and fresh acidity, with a lacelike texture dancing across
the palate, although there is solid structure and potential for development
clearly evident. Nevertheless, at present it is one-dimensional and shallow,
with just a little citrus and floral character. This is indicative of the
lighter, delicate styles which can be found in the 2002 vintage; this needs a
long slumber in the cellar before it will show great interest. 17+/20
![]()
Chateau Bellerive Quarts de Chaume 1997:
A deep, golden-orange hue. A fantastic nose, rich with aromas of orange
marmalade, apricot and honey. There is plenty of botrytis influence here. It has
a rich, palate-coating, impressive presence. Minerality and botrytis-derived
richness combined, with a vein of fresh acidity to maintain balance. This is
stunning stuff indeed. Although I suggested this needs years in the cellar, it
is still approachable now, although it will certainly age slowly and gracefully. 19+/20
![]()
Chateau Bellerive Quarts de Chaume Quintessence 1997: Very deep,
burnished gold. Intense nose, with even greater depth than the straight
1997.Caramel, honey, toffee, maple syrup, beeswax and more; what an incredible
nose. Great depth and the evolution of complexity is apparent on the palate.
Glorious, opulent, rich yet fresh, although as previously noted acidity does
seem to be on the low side. Long, lingering finish. The greatest example of QdC
I have tasted, showing just that little bit more convincingly than my last
tasting, and compared to the straight cuvée. Stunning. 19.5/20
![]()
Domaine des Baumard Quarts de Chaume 2001: From a half bottle. Mid-golden hue.
Beautiful nose, of barley sugar and oranges, with chalky, talcy, mineral notes
bringing up the rear. Full, creamy style on the palate, simply laden with exotic
flavours; oranges and other citrus fruits, flowers, lychees even. Mineral and
with great acidity, with a lovely weight and presence. Previously showing quite
a caramel note, this is much less evident today. Drink over the next 20 years.
Stunning. 19+/20
![]()
